So, another breaking news event has come and gone, and the Twit-Folks are convinced it has provided further evidence that Social Media has MSM on the run.
Here is the “news” as reported by a twitter user involved in the crash:
Holy f*g s*t I wasbjust in a plane crash! 8:25 PM Dec 20th from twitterrific
Ugh … My glasses fell off in the mass exodus getting off the plane .. Can’t see very well 8:57 PM Dec 20th from twitterrific
This was crash #2 for me. Maybe I should start taking the bus. 8:58 PM Dec 20th from twitterrific
Can’t see much, but that’s the crash site. http://twitpic.com/ut2c 9:35 PM Dec 20th from twitterrific
Continental keeping us locked up at the presidents club until they can sort everything out. Won’t even serve us drinks.
11:21 PM Dec 20th from twitterrific
… and by this point MSM is well underway on the story.
By the way, if you work with this guy and ever have to travel … take a separate flight.
Anyway nothing against the tweeter. Considering he was under duress I think providing any info at all was an accomplishment.
The point is, if you happen to be one of his followers and suddenly get those tweets, so what? You don’t know jack other than that you need to turn on the TV or log on to a MSM news site and find out what is going on. And, as one commentator to the post linked above mentioned – you can’t really even be sure this guy was actually in the crash.
Elsewhere I have read “I followed it on Twitter,” or “I followed it on Facebook.” Great. But I’m willing to bet Twitter or Facebook, in those situations, was merely serving as a relay. That user might have been getting info there, but somewhere on up the food chain you’ll find a user who was tuned into MSM and passing the info along. No harm in that, but just don’t represent it as Social Media getting over on MSM.
I think it will happen as these sites mature (if they can continue to find investors who will subsidize their operating at a loss). As events go down, users will live blog, tweet, or update with real “on the scene” information and beat the big news boys to some interesting details.
But it seems like before we can get to that point, a whole bunch of Social Media fanatics need to tone down their campaign to sell the world on Social Media. This has become the new global warming. Whatever happens, however inconsequential, it somehow stands as proof that Twitter is the most awesome thing ever in the history of man and if you don’t see that you’re lame. When there is real value to be seen, no one will notice because by then they’ll be too sick of the Twit-folk attempts to conjure up value where there isn’t any.
These sites / tools are making progress. Irrational pushing isn’t going to help things.