Well, I was surprised. After Project Runway, Top (Interior) Designer, and Top Hair Stylist or whatever it was called I figured that next up on Bravo’s parade of trades heavily populated by gay men would be some sort of competition for ChiChi’s waiters. Instead we are treated to another installment of Top Chef. Time will tell if we are looking at a cast of refreshing real people who are actually about the cooking as in season one, or a batch of whiny pissants, one of whom unfortunately, must win, as in season two.
Since it’s too early to start in on a blow by blow, let me talk instead about the short shelf life of reality show concepts.
As long as the concept isn’t lame, the first one or two seasons of a reality show are usually pretty good. The players arrive not knowing any better, so they embrace the actual premise of the show.
Then the dark side of reality sets in. Suddenly the cast members have agents on retainer before filming begins. They show up ready to fit into a reality role; the bad guy, the good guy, the eccentric, etc.
In TC3, Hung proclaimed himself the bad guy in his opening vignette.
See, that doesn’t work. The real bad guy doesn’t come through the door introducing themselves as the bad guy. In fact, as with Bada-Bing Betty and her ubiquitious cleavage from TC2, the bad guy may even think, or try to convince others that they are the good guy.
The problem with the role playing is that suddenly you’ve got half the cast more intent on making a big splash in hopes that their name will live beyond the show, than on actually winning.
It’s all downhill after that. Just ask Donald Trump … if you can get him to admit it.