Dick Morris has posted his recommendations for McCain’s Veep selection. I agree with him a little.
First of all though, I think we’re all way off base in assuming that the selection will be some shrewd, calculating maneuver which will give flight to McCain’s dull effort. Strategy and wisdom have been absent from the Arizona Senator’s campaign since he locked up the nomination. I don’t know why we should assume that those things will suddenly appear when he picks a partner.
Morris argues that Mitt Romney would be a bad choice. Romney comes with some strong negatives, and how valuable is a guy who couldn’t attract conservative votes for himself going to be? I agree but for different reasons. As flawed as Romney’s primary campaign was, right now Conservatives are still squeamish about voting for McCain, so any conservative, however bland they may be would help.
However, I never like the idea of selecting someone you previously had to bash during the primaries. Maybe you can dance around inevitable “Back in March you said __, but now all of a sudden you think this person is the greatest thing since sliced bread,” inquiries. Sure those questions can be handled, but is that what you want to be talking about? If you succeed you’ll have convinced American that you are ok with your running mate. You automatically increase the time and effort spent off message, and McCain isn’t sharp enough when he’s on message to afford that.
Morris suggests Condi Rice or Colin Powell. Personally I like both, but I’m not sure it would be the strong strategic answer to Obama’s appeal that Morris thinks. I remember when Walter Mondale tagged Geraldine Ferraro to be his running mate. It was not hailed as a groundbreaking event in American political history. The reaction was more like, “Wow, you really ARE desperate.”
Joe Lieberman is Morris’ other choice. I can see that, and again I like the guy. But, Lieberman didn’t used to be a Democrat by accident. He’s strong on defense and has some other conservative-friendly positions. Like that. He stuck his thumb in Hillary’s eye by running as an independent and winning after her coalition ran him out of the party nomination for his seat. Love that, and even more I love thinking of him roaming around the Senate chamber not owing the party that tried to screw him a damn thing. I’d kind of like him to stay there. Plus, in many other ways he is a liberal.
Part of my difficulty is that I’ve already mentally given up on this election. There is no foresee-able outcome that I can get excited about, other than the hope that receiving a sound ass-kicking will motivate Republicans to return to their “Contract with America” spirit. So, I must admit that I like the idea of a McCain / Lieberman ticket based on entertainment value alone. I’m just a bit concerned about what might happen beyond that if it were to succeed. It’s similar to how, on the Democratic side I’d love to see an Obama / Clinton ticket because I believe that would be a full-on three-ring circus. The quest for a little fun is at war with my desire to be rid of the Clinton scourge once and for all.
Honestly, I don’t know who McCain should pick. Please, God, not Huckabee. That little imp is really starting to get on my nerves. He became the default outlet for a lot of conservative votes in search of a place to land, and he’s playing it like it was about him.
Also, it’s kind of difficult to suggest the possibility of wasting any real conservative talent on designated ceremony-attender duty in the shadow of McCain. If I thought that a McCain administration would set the #2 guy up for a strong run in ’12 maybe. But I just don’t see McCain displaying that kind of competence or experiencing that kind of success.